When we recently moved to Albany – 43 years ago now – the house we purchased started out as one of the turn-of-the century weekend cottages that dot Albany: two tiny bedrooms, one small bath, and a combination living room-dining-kitchen. Along the way, a bigger bedroom and then a wacky bathroom were tacked on back.
A couple of years before we purchased the house, two guys – a master cabinet maker and an electrician – worked for over a year to remodel the house literally from the ground up. In their remodeling, they created a galley kitchen to make room for a hallway and laundry space.
As you can imagine, there is no room in that narrow kitchen. At best, there’s room for one person – who spends a lot of time walking from one end to the other. Once the refrigerator door is open, no one is going in or out. Fortunately, the oven door has a sign that reads “For display purposes only.”
Of course, it’s almost impossible to avoid having two people in the kitchen. And when we have company, they gravitate there as well. So, especially in the last 20 years, there have been lots of dirty looks and cross words spoken.
And, because I’m never happy and always complaining, I’ve lately felt that this sanctuary at St. Alban’s is too big. I try to put the rosy glasses on, and I know the historical and demographic reasons why fewer people are in church on Sunday mornings. But I really don’t like all these empty pews.
That’s why today’s Gospel is such good news. This passage appears only in Matthew’s Gospel, and it is often misinterpreted and misused. It becomes a pretext for removing people from the church, excluding those who don’t toe the line. And then labeling those who are kicked out as “tax collectors and Gentiles.”
But the narrative pattern of Matthew’s Gospel – admittedly not transparent to modern readers – has a very different message.
It’s the same message we hear at that pivotal point in Matthew’s Gospel when Peter –the model disciple – finds himself in rough seas and sinking. The message to Peter is “Take Jesus’ hand and get back in the boat with all the other disciples.”
And this boat – the church – has room for everyone. Especially those who seem outside the boat. Especially those who are tax collectors and Gentiles.
Matthew’s Gospel begins with a genealogy that includes a number of questionable characters – foreigners and women. Early on in a dream, Joseph is urged to take a pregnant woman as his wife. Wise men from the East come to worship Jesus. The newborn child immigrates to Egypt.
Later on, Jesus makes Matthew, a tax collector –the equivalent of an ICE agent – as a disciple. A Roman Centurion – one of Hegseth’s testosterone generals – has his son healed. Jesus calls a Gentile woman called a “dog” – and then goes on to lift up her faith and save her daughter’s life.
Of the course, the church has a long history of excluding people, of saying “not for you” whether because of your skin color or social class or – for we Book of Prayer People – a little too much enthusiasm and innovation for our taste.
This spirit of not enough room has now infected our national politics and that of many other countries. Better to be without doctors or farm workers so we can have only those people around us who confirm our own sense of nostalgia and superiority. Just as troubling, some are saying there’s no room in the workplace or the voting booth for women.
But the passages immediately before and after today’s Gospel reading are clear: in the church, there is room enough for everyone. And, at a time when ten men were required for a synagogue, it takes only two or three to make a church – a church that can move mountains.
The even better – and more surprising – good news is that this gathering of two, three, or 300 is going to experience conflict, disagreement, and suffering. Indeed, this tension is welcomed because this is the way the church lives out God’s endless, overflowing, never give-up-mercy.
For Matthew’s first readers, welcoming everyone and reconciling conflicts were not goals or imperatives, but what was actually happening in their community. It was happening because the Risen Christ was present among them. Christ’s Spirit supplied the sparks, the connections, the push-and-pull between those gathered in Christ’s name.
Following today’s reading, we have another passage that appears only in Matthew: Peter, our star pupil, asks about how many times he should forgive his brother. Seventy times seven was the answer. In other words, as many times as it takes. With Christ at its center, nothing can tear this church apart.
To make this even clearer, Jesus tells the parable of the rich man who forgives a debt of 10,000 talents. In Greek, 10,000 is the largest number, and a talent was the heaviest coin.
All our debts can be paid, our burdens lifted, because in the next chapter, Jesus leaves Galilee and begins his journey to Jerusalem. There, his execution on the cross – at the hands of both the religious authorities and the Roman rulers – is a ransom for many. The earth shakes and the dead rise up from their graves.
Then, at the very end of Matthew’s Gospel, we go back to mountain in Galilee. There, as we heard today, that where two or three our gathered in his name, the risen Christ will always be with us.
Today’s Gospel is part of the fourth of five discourses in Matthew. The first was the so-called Sermon on the Mount where we are taught to pray, “Our father, your will be done on earth as in heaven.”
In Matthew, Jesus announces the kingdom of heaven. In Mark and Luke, it’s the kingdom of God. With his teaching and healing, Jesus is bringing the kingdom of heaven into daily life.
So, it’s no surprise that at the end of today’s reading, we hear that what is happening in our community – welcoming everyone and resolving our conflicts – is actually taking place in heaven.
For Matthew, heaven is not some place in the sky. Heaven is wherever God is, and Jesus sits at God’s right hand. As we hear at the very start of Matthew, Jesus is to be called Immanuel: God with us.
Those of gathered today will soon – in our Prayers of the People – remember those saints who have died. We do so, knowing that they are among us, singing and praying. They are breathing the Spirit of Christ into us. For these saints, what makes their lives so heavenly is that they are part of the life eternal we are living right now.
So, you see, these pews aren’t so empty after all. The prayers we offer and the songs we sing have many voices joining ours. It’s all very heavenly. Amen.